Job market paper
Loyalty, Competence, and the Allocation of Office under Threat
Evidence from Qing China
How does the kind of threat a state faces change which offices rulers give to hereditary insiders? Using annual records of provincial officials in Qing China, 1825–1911, I compare changes in the representation of the Eight Banners after rebellions and foreign wars. The Banner share of governors-general and governors rose after rebellion, while no rise is detected after foreign war. The rise is clearest in the governor-generalship and is concentrated in the rebellions dated to 1853. The evidence is consistent with a loyalty–competence trade-off in appointments to offices commanding troops, although differences in responses across executive, fiscal and judicial offices are not statistically established.
Updated
Read paper PDF